How to compare home care providers before you switch

3 minute read Updated 7 October 2026

An older couple comparing home care information booklets at their dining table

Changing providers can feel like a big step. A few clear questions make it easier to compare. When you compare home care providers, you're looking for the one that fits your life, not the one with the longest list of services. Many providers offer similar services. What differs is how they deliver them day to day.

Before you start, write down the support you need, the times it matters and how you would like to be involved in decisions. Use the same list with every provider, so you are comparing answers rather than impressions.

Start with the support you need

Separate what is essential from what is a preference. Help getting ready for an appointment may need a set time. A household task may be more flexible.

Tell each provider your suburb, the tasks involved and how often you need them. Ask which services the local team can deliver now and which depend on availability.

Compare the proposed care, not just the price

Ask each provider for a written proposal that lists the services, visit lengths and prices. Check that you are comparing the same things: the same tasks, the same days and the same amount of time.

A lower hourly price does not tell you whether the arrangement covers everything you need. Ask about minimum visit lengths, weekend and public holiday prices, and any other charges.

Under Support at Home, you pay contributions only on the services you receive, and you do not contribute to clinical supports. Ask each provider to show how its proposal fits your budget and which contributions apply to you.

Look at how the care plan is put together

A care plan should set out your goals, the services you will receive and how your budget will be used. It should be in plain language and reflect what you asked for, not only what the provider usually offers.

Ask each provider to walk you through its proposed plan, and check:

  • Does it include the services and goals you raised?

  • Is the budget broken down in a way you can follow?

  • How and when will the plan be reviewed?

How a provider explains its plan can tell you as much as what is written down.

Need help working out your options?

Talk to a local team about the support you need

No obligation, and we’ll explain your options in plain English.

Get started Or call 1300 875 377

Get a feel for how the team works

Ask how the provider matches care workers to the people they support, what training workers have for the kind of support you need, and who supervises them. If you have a language, cultural or personal preference, ask how it will be recorded and shared with the people who support you.

Pay attention to the first conversations too. Are your calls returned? Are the answers clear, or do you have to ask twice?

Things to check before you decide

It is worth pausing before you sign if you notice any of these:

  • prices or charges that are hard to get in writing

  • reluctance to show you a proposed care plan

  • slow or vague answers to straightforward questions

  • promises about outcomes or start dates that sound too certain

Read the service agreement before you decide. My Aged Care explains what a Support at Home service agreement covers.

Keep a simple comparison record

For each provider, note the services offered, the proposed visit times, the written prices, your main contact and any questions still open. Mark something as confirmed only when the provider has actually answered it.

Compare HomeCaring with your other options

Talk to your local HomeCaring team or call 1300 875 377 about the support you need and the questions on your list. We will tell you what the local team can offer and what still needs to be confirmed.

Talk to our care team

Tell us what’s happening and we’ll help you work out the right support at home.

Make an enquiry